Used Toner Cartridges Become Channel for Leaking Secret Information in China
A case in China has revealed that secret state information can be recovered from used toner cartridges. This recovered information has been sold to foreign organizations.

In China, incidents have surfaced where used toner cartridges from printers have been exploited to extract and leak secret state information. Even after cartridges are discarded, residual data can be restored using specialized tools and subsequently sold to foreign entities.
In one disclosed case, an office supply vendor, posing as an environmental recycler, collected used toner cartridges from a government unit. An employee at the unit handed over these cartridges, which contained substantial classified state secrets.
The vendor was able to recover outlines of the printed documents by analyzing residual electrostatic charges or toner distribution on the drum surface using specialized techniques. This recovered information was then sold to foreign organizations. The vendor was subsequently apprehended and convicted for espionage, with the involved employee facing disciplinary action.
The incident underscores the critical need for organizations to strictly differentiate between classified and non-classified information equipment and manage them accordingly. Authorities emphasize adherence to strict confidentiality regulations throughout the lifecycle of classified equipment, including its disposal. Storage components must undergo professional data erasure or physical destruction before being decommissioned to prevent the leakage of state secrets and irreparable damage.